Amēkhaníē in Parmênides DK B 6.5

Authors

  • Nicola Stefano Galgano Universidade de São Paulo

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.1981-9471.v10i2p1-12

Keywords:

Parmenides, eleaticism, ancient psychology, ancient epistemology, mortals.

Abstract

The paper examines closer the notion expressed by the word amēkhaníē in DK 6. 5. In his analysis of problematic of knowledge Parmenides alerts about amekhaníē of mortals, a word generally translated with `lack of resources` or ‘perplexity’, a kind of problem that drives the thinking astray. Scholars point out in many passages of the poem the opposition between imperfect mortals and the eidóta phōta of DK 1. 3, the wise man.  However, as much as I know, nobody noticed that, if mortals have a lack of resources, the goddess is teaching exactly how to fix it with a kind of method given through her precepts, which are an authentic mēchané. The paper shows that this is the genuine didactic aim of Parmenides, as he says in 1.28-30, i.e., to point out where is the error of mortals and how the wise man fixes it. Starting from a reinterpretation of 1.29 and following with the analysis of fr. 6, the paper shows that the method of fr. 2 is indeed the mēchané that can do that. Although the word is not present in the poem, it is one of its main topics. It seems (by the extant fragments) Parmenides had no clear word to call his mēchané, a psychological cognitive tool we call today principle of non-contradiction.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

  • Nicola Stefano Galgano, Universidade de São Paulo
    Post-doc researcher

References

Barnes, J. (1982) The Presocratic philosophers. 2a. ed. revisada, reimpressão 2000, Routledge, Londres. DOI: 10.4324/9780203007372

Beaufret, J. (1955) Le poème de Parménide. Presses universitaires de France, Paris.

Capizzi, A. (1975), Introduzione a Parmenide. Ed. Laterza, Bari.

Cavalcante de Souza, J. (dir.) (1978) Os pré-socráticos. Ed. Abril Cultural, São Paulo.

Cordero, N.-L. (1984) Les deux chemins de Parménide. Édition critique, traduction, études et bibliographie. Ed. Vrin, Paris et Ousia, Bruxelles.

Cordero, N.-L. (2005), Siendo, se es. Ed. Editorial Biblos, Buenos Aires.

Coxon, A. H. (2009) The fragments of Parmenides – Revised and expanded edition – Parmenides Publishing, Las Vegas.

Diels, H. e Kranz, W. (1989) Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker. Reimpressão da 6a edição de 1951. Ed. Weidmann, Zurich.

Frere, J. (2011) Mortals (βροτοὶ) according to Parmenides. In Cordero, N-L (editor) (2011) Parmênides, venerable and awesome. Ed. Parmenides Publishing, Las Vegas.

Galgano, N. S. (2012) DK 28 1.29 – A verdade tem um coração intrépido? In AAVV Una mirada actual a la filosofia griega. Ponencias del II Congreso Internacional de Filosofia Griega, Ediciones de la SIFG, Madrid-Mallorca

Lattimore, R. (1951) The Iliad of Homer. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Lesher, J. H. (2001) Xenophanes. University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

Long, A.A. (1975) The principles of Parmenides' cosmogony. In (ed. Allen, R. E. e Furley, D. J.) Studies in Presocratic Philosophy, vol II, pp. 82-101, Ed. Humanities Press, Atlantic Highlands,

Mansfeld, J. (1960) Die Offenbarung des Parmenides und die menschliche Welt. Assen.

Palmer, J. (2009) Parmenides and the presocratic phylosophy. Ed. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Reale, G. (1991) I frammenti del poema di Parmenide “Sulla natura” - traduzione e note. In Reale, G. e Ruggiu, L. Parmenide, Poema sulla natura. Rusconi, Milão.

Rietzer, K. - Gadamer, H. G. (1970) Parmenides. Ed. Vittorio Klostermann, Frankfurt am Main.

Ruggiu, L. (1975) Parmenide. Marsilio Editori, Venezia.

Santoro, F. (2011) Filósofos épicos I – Parmênides e Xenófanes. Fundação Biblioteca Nacional, Hexis, Rio de Janeiro.

Somville, P. (1976) Parménide d'Élée, son temps et le nôtre. Vrin, Paris.

Taylor, C. C. W. (1999) The atomists Leucippus and Democritus. University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

Untersteiner, M. (1979) Parmenide, testimonianze e frammenti. La Nuova Italia, Firenze.

Zeller, E. (1967) La filosofia de Greci nel suo svluppo storico. Parte I, I presocratici. Volume III. Eleati. 5th edition. Italian translation by Rodolfo Mondolfo; expanded edition by G. Reale. Firenze.

Downloads

Published

2016-11-01

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Galgano, N. S. (2016). Amēkhaníē in Parmênides DK B 6.5. Journal of Ancient Philosophy, 10(2), 1-12. https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.1981-9471.v10i2p1-12