Philosophers on Stage: From Aristophanes’ Socrates to Timon of Phlius’ Parody to Construct a New Philosophy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.1981-9471.v20i1p86-103Keywords:
Timon of Phlius, Socrates, Aristophanes, Plato, XENOPHON, Satire, ComedyAbstract
This article aims to illustrate some intersections between Greek philosophical satire and ancient Greek philosophy by discussing the Pyrrhonian satire of Timon of Phlius against the philosophy of Socrates and his followers. Timonian mockery operates not only through literary strategies such as ὀνομαστὶ κομῳδεῖν, a hallmark of Aristophanic Old Comedy, but also through caricatures of Socrates’ ideas and their reception, captured by the term “Philosophenspott”. Analysing this philosophical mockery opens new avenues for studying how ancient authors, including Timon, used satire both to undermine rival doctrines and also to articulate their own doctrines
Downloads
References
AELIUS ARISTIDES, In Platonem, 16. Ed. by Behr, Charles A., & Lenz, Friedrich W. (1976,) P. Aelii Aristidis Opera quae extant omnia, vol. 1, Leiden: Brill.
ARISTOPHANES, Aves, 1553 – 1564. Ed. by Zanetto, Giuseppe, & del Corno, Dario (1987), Aristofane. Gli Uccelli, Rome: Arnoldo Mondadori Editore.
ARISTOPHANES, Nubes, 218 – 411; 842; 949 – 1104. Ed. by Grilli, Alessandro (2001), Aristofane. Le Nuvole. Introduzione, traduzione e note, Milan: RCS Libri S.p.A.
ARISTOPHANES, Ranae, 153. Ed. by Wilson, Nigel G. (2007), Aristophanis Fabulae. Tomus II, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
ATHENAEUS OF NAUCRATIS, Deipnosophistai, 35. Ed. by Kaibel, Georg (1966), Athenaei Naucratitae deipnosophistarum libri xv, 3 vols., Leipzig: Teubner.
ATTARDO, S. (2018): “Universals in puns and humorous wordplay”, in Winter-Froemel, & Thaler (eds.), Cultures and Traditions of Wordplay and Wordplay Research (pp. 89 – 110), De Gruyter: Boston – Berlin.
AX, W. (1991): “Timons Gang in die Unterwelt: Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der antiken Literaturparodie”, Hermes, 119, 2:177 – 193.
BATTEZZATO, L. (2008): “Pythagorean comedies from Epicharmus to Alexis”, Aevum Antiquum, S.8:139 – 164.
BETT, R. (2019): “Humor as Philosophical Subversion: Especially in the Skeptics”, in DESTRÉE, & TRIVIGNO (eds.), Laughter, Humor, and Comedy in Ancient Philosophy (pp. 208 – 226), Oxford: Oxford University Press.
BLIQUEZ, L.J. (2008): “The “Πυρρικη” of Kinesias, a Pun? Aristophanes “Frogs” 153”, The Classical Quarterly, 58, 1:320 – 326.
BRAGUES, G. (2004): “The Market for Philosophers: An Interpretation of Lucian’s Satire on Philosophy”, The Independent Review, 9, 2:227 – 251.
BRICKHOUSE, T.C., & SMITH, N.D. (2006): “Socrates and the Laws of Athen”, Philosophy Compass, 1, 6:564 – 570.
CACIAGLI, S., NAPOLITANO, M., TREU, M. (2016): “Prologhi aristofanei: variabili e costanti in apertura di commedia”, in CACIAGLI, DE SANCTIS, GIOVANNELLI, REGALI (eds.), Lessico del Comico, I (pp. 98 – 134), Università degli Studi di Milano: Milano.
CALLIAS, Fragmenta, 15. Ed. by KASSEL, R., & AUSTIN, C. (1983), Poetae Comici Graeci. Vol. IV. Aristophon – Crobylus, Berlin – New York: De Gruyter.
CANFORA, L. (2011), Il Mondo di Atene, Bari – Rome: Gius. Laterza & Figli Spa.
CHRISTIANS, M. (2023): “Recherches sur la typologie des corrections et le stade de composition de la Ptôcheia d’Ulysse à Troie dans le PKöln VI 245”, Studi di Egittologia e di Papirologia, 20:69 – 84.
CLAYMAN, D. L. (2009), Timon of Phlius. Pyrrhonism into Poetry, Berlin – New York: De Gruyter.
DIODORUS SICULUS, Bibliotheca historica, 20, 63, 3. Ed. by FISCHER, K.T. & VOGEL, F. (1964), Diodori bibliotheca historica, 5 vols., 3rd edn., Leipzig: Teubner.
DIOGENES LAERTIUS, Vitae Philosophorum, 2, 19 - 20. Ed. by HICKS, R. D. (1925), Diogenes Laertius. Lives of Eminent Philosophers, Volume I: Books 1-5, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
EDMUNDS, L. (1987): “Il Socrate aristofaneo e l’ironia pratica”, Quaderni Urbinati di Cultura Classica, 26, 2:7 – 21.
FENK, R. (1913), Adversarii Platonis. Quomodo de indole ac moribus eius iudicaverint, Jena: Typis G. Neuenhahni.
GALLO, I. (1987): “Il giudizio di Timone di Fliunte su Socrate (Diog. Laert. II 19)”, in: GRIMAL, LANA, LA PENNA, LLOYD-JONES, MANTERO, PÖSCHL, QUESTA (eds.), Filologia e forme letterarie. Vol. I (pp. 327 – 333), Università degli Studi di Urbino: Urbino.
GELZER, T. (1956): “Aristophanes und sein Sokrates”, Museum Helveticum, 13, 2:65 – 93.
GEMIN, M. (2018): “Platone incantatore: Phaed. 78a”, Wiener Studien, 131:7 – 12.
GIANNANTONI, G. (1990), Socrates et Socraticorum Reliquiae. Volumen I, Naples: Bibliopolis.
GREY, W.R. (1896), The Treatment of Philosophy and Philosophers by the Greek Comic Poets, Baltimore: The Firedenwald Company.
HEGESENADER OF DELPHIS, Fragmenta, 2. Ed. by MÜLLER, K. (1870), Fragmenta historicorum Graecorum (FHG) 4, Paris: Didot.
HELM, R. (1906), Lucian und Menipp, Leipzig: Teubner.
IDOMENEUES OF LAMPSACUS, Fragmenta, 1. Ed. by MÜLLER, K. (1870), Fragmenta historicorum Graecorum (FHG) 2, Paris: Didot.
IMPERIO, O. (1998): “La figura dell’intellettuale nella commedia greca”, in BELARDINELLI, IMPERIO, MASTROMARCO, PELLEGRINO, TOTARO (eds.), Tessere. Frammenti della commedia greca: studi e commenti (pp. 43 – 130), Bari: Adriatica.
LIDDELL, H.G., & SCOTT, R. (1996), «ἠθολόγος», A Greek-English Lexicon, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
LUCIAN, Vitarum auctio. Ed. by HARMON, A. M. (1915), Lucian. Works. With an English Translation, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
DI MARCO, M. (1989), Timone di Fliunte. Silli. Introduzione, edizione critica, traduzione e commento, Rome: Edizioni dell’Ateneo.
MASTELLARI, V. (2020): “Πυθαγορισμοί e retorica: il trattamento dei filosofi pitagorici in due frammenti comici di IV secolo a.C. (Cratin. Iun. fr. 7 e Alex. fr. 223 K.-A.)”, Rhesis. International Journal of Linguistics, Philology and Literature, 11, 1:95 – 104.
MICHELINI, A.N. (1998): “ΠΟΛΛΗ ΑΓΡΟΙΚΙΑ: Rudeness and Irony in Plato’s Gorgias”, Classical Philology, 93, 1:50 – 59.
NESSELRATH H.G. (1985), Lukians Parasitendialog. Untersuchungen und Kommentar, Berlin – New York: De Gruyter.
NESSELRATH, H.G. (1990), Die attische Mittlere Komödie, Berlin – New York: De Gruyter.
NESSELRATH H.G. (2001): “Lukian und die antike Philosophie”, in Ebner, Gzella, Nesselrath, Ribbat (eds.), Lukian. ΦΙΛΟΨΕΥΔΕΙΣ Η ΑΠΙΣΤΩΝ. Die Lügenfreunde oder: der Ungläubige (pp. 135 – 152), Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft.
PADUANO, G. (1990), Aristofane. Le Vespe. Gli Uccelli. Nuova traduzione con testo a fronte, Milan: Garzanti Editore s.p.a.
PAPIÓR, J. (1985): “Von der Phrontisterie und dem Atticismus zur offenen Möglichkeitsleben. Versuch einer Typologie diachronischer Ironieformen”, Zagadnienia Rodzajów Literackich, XXVI, 2:41 – 58.
PAUSANIAS, Periegesis, 10, 24, 1 – 2. Ed. by SPIRO, F. (1967), Pausaniae Graeciae descriptio, 3 vols., Leipzig: Teubner.
PHOTIUS, Lexicon, η, 81. Ed. by THEODORIDIS, C. (1998), Photii patriarchae lexicon (Ε—Μ), vol. 2, Berlin – New York: De Gruyter.
PLATO, Apologia, 19c; 29c – d. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 1, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Charmides, 164e – 165a. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 3, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Crito. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 1, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Gorgias. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 3, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Meno. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 3, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Phaedo. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 1, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Phaedrus. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 2, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Philebus. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 2, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Symposium. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 2, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLATO, Theaetetus. Ed. by BURNET, J. (1967), Platonis opera, vol. 1, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
PLUTARCH, Quaestiones convivales, 673b, 3. Ed. by HUBERT, K. (1971), Plutarchi moralia, vol. 4, Leipzig: Teubner.
QUINTILIAN, Institutio Oratoria, VI, 3, 105 – 112. Ed. by RUSSELL, D. A. (2002), Quintilian. The Orator's Education. Volume I. Books 1-2, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
ROSS, S. (1974): “Caricature”, The Monist, 58, 2:285 – 293.
SAMPINO, F. (2012): “Linguaggio parafilosofico e parasocratico nelle Nuvole di Aristofane”, Dionysus ex machina, III:80 – 128: https://dionysusexmachina.it/linguaggio-parafilosofico-e-parasocratico-nelle-nuvole-di-aristofane/.
SANCHIS LLOPIS, J.L. (1995): “Los Pitagóricos en la Comedia Media: Parodia filosófica y Comedia de Tipos”, Habis, 26:67 – 82.
SEXTUS EMPIRICUS, Adversus Mathematicos, VII, 8 – 10. Ed. by MAU, J., MUTSCHMANN, H. (1914), Sexti Empirici opera, vols. 2 & 3, 2nd edn., Leipzig: Teubner.
SOPHOCLES, Antigones, 21 – 46; 161 – 210. Ed. by LLOYD-JONES, & WILSON (1990), Sophoclis fabulae, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
STAVRU, A. (2021): “Pythagoreische Seelenreisen bei Aristophanes: Katabasis als transformativer Wissenserwerb”, in MÄNNLEIN-ROBERT, I. (ed.), Seelenreise und Katabasis ins Jenseits in antiker philosophischer Literatur (pp. 139 – 176), Boston – Berlin: De Gruyter.
STAVRU, A. (2023): “Pythagorean topoi in Aristophanes’ Birds 1553 – 1564”, Ancient Philosophy, 43:1 – 20.
STOREY, I.C. (2011), Fragments of Old Comedy. Volume I. Alcaeus to Diocles, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
TAGLIALATELA, G. (forthcoming): “Timon von Phleius und der Spott über Zenon und die stoische Schule”, in HITZ, & KRÄMER, Lehrer und Schüler in der Antike, Zürich: LIT.
TIMON OF PHLIUS, Fragmenta, 781; 787; 799; 812; 813; 818; 819; 836. Ed. by LLOYD-JONES, &
PARSONS (1983), Supplementum Hellenisticum, Berlin – New York: De Gruyter.
VLASTOS, G. (1987): “Socratic irony”, The Classical Quarterly, 37, 1:79 – 86.
VLASTOS, G. (1991), Socrates. Ironist and moral Philosopher, Cambridge: University Press.
WEIHER, A. (1913), Philosophen und Philosophenspott in der attischen Komödie, Nordlingen: Beck.
WEIL, S. (1953), “Intuitions pré-chétienne”, Oeuvres complètes, voll. I/2, II/3, IV/2:1 – 39.
WILLIAMS, D.D. (2022): “Socrates and “the Sophists” in Old Comedy”, TAPA, 152, 2:345 – 379.
XENOPHON, Memorabilia, I, 3, 8; I, 1, 11; IV, 2, 24; IV, 4. Ed. by MARCHANT, E. C.(1971), Xenophontis opera omnia, vol. 2, 2nd edn., Oxford: Clarendon Press.
ZANETTO, G. (2010): “I filosofi a teatro? Fanno ridere. Le “Nuvole” di Aristofane”, in COSTAZZA, A. (ed.), La filosofia a teatro (pp. 135 – 150), Milan: Cisalpino.
ZIMMERMANN, B. (1993): “Aristophanes und die Intellektuelle”, Entretiens sur l’Antiquité classique, 38:255 – 286.
ZIMMERMANN, B. (2023): “Pythagoristen. Philosophenspott in der griechischen Komödie”, in SEMENZATO, & HARTMANN (eds.), Von der Antike begeistert! Philologie, Philosophie, Religion und Politik durch drei Jahrtausende (pp. 39 – 58), Geneve: Fondation Hardt.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Giovanni Taglialatela
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License (CC By 4.0) that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
