Cultural consumers’ gatekeeping in cosplay: cynical truths established through fans’ practice
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1108/REGE-01-2025-0021Keywords:
Gatekeeping, Cosplay, Consumer communities, Cynicism, Netnographic Foucauldian genealogyAbstract
PurposeCultural consumer gatekeeping shapes interactions with the marketplace, indicating that participatory culture and fans' practices – such as cosplay – can establish truth games in fan culture. Thus, this study aims to examine how cultural consumers’ gatekeeping establishes truth games in fan practice.
Design/methodology/approachThe methodological approach integrates Foucault’s analytical framework with the netnographic data collection, which considered cosplayer interactions over five years.
FindingsTwo power diagrams structure cosplayers’ resistance. Disillusion reflects opposition to perceived distortions, such as external appropriations and the politicization of cosplay. Depravity captures the tensions surrounding hypersexualized performance, balancing artistic expression and community norms. By navigating these conflicts, they enact the consumer truths that regulate participation in a gatekeeping process, where community members assert authority over acceptable practices and reinforce participatory culture through internal governance and exclusionary mechanisms.
Social implicationsThis study reveals how consumer communities self-regulate through internal truth production, shaping participatory cultures. Practically, it provides insights for marketing researchers to navigate cultural sensitivities, helping them engage with fandom while respecting governance and authenticity.
Originality/valueThis study contributes and conceptualizes cultural gatekeeping as a disposition of cynical consumer resistance and expanding knowledge on how consumer truths shape inclusion, exclusion and power structures in digital fandoms.
Downloads
References
Arnould, E. J., Thompson, C. J., & Press, M. (2020). Consumer Culture Theory: An Anthropological Contribution to Consumption Studies. In The Routledge Companion to Anthropology and Business (pp. 118-131). Routledge.
Beckett, A. (2012). Governing the consumer: technologies of consumption. Consumption Markets & Culture, 15(1), 1-18.
Camargo, T. I., de Souza-Leão, A. L. M., & Moura, B. M. (2022). Resisting to Game of Thrones: a fannish agonism. Revista de Gestão, 29(1), 55-75.
Cavalcanti, R. C., Souza-Leão, A. L., & Moura, B. M. (2021). Hipsters versus posers: Fannish split in the indie music world. RAM. Revista de Administração Mackenzie, 22(3). 1-28.
Chen, Z. T. (2021). Poetic prosumption of animation, comic, game and novel in a post-socialist China: A case of a popular video-sharing social media Bilibili as heterotopia. Journal of Consumer Culture, 21(2), 257-277.
Cristofari, C., & Guitton, M. J. (2017). Aca-fans and fan communities: An operative framework. Journal of Consumer Culture, 17(3), 713-731.
Cronin, J., & Hopkinson, G. (2018). Bodysnatching in the marketplace: Market-focused health activism and compelling narratives of dys-appearance. Marketing Theory, 18(3), 269-286.
De Mello, R. R., De Almeida, S. O., & Dalmoro, M. (2021). The emperor’s new cosplay: the agency of an absent material on the consumption experience. Consumption Markets & Culture, 24(3), 241-261.
Denegri-Knott, J., Nixon, E., & Abraham, K. (2018). Politicising the study of sustainable living practices. Consumption Markets & Culture, 21(6), 554-573.
Drenten, J., Harrison, R. L., & Pendarvis, N. J. (2023). More gamer, less girl: gendered boundaries, tokenism, and the cultural persistence of masculine dominance. Journal of Consumer Research, 50(1), 2-24.
Foucault, M. (1981). Sexuality and solitude. London Review of Books, 3(9), 3-7.
Foucault, M. (2011). The courage of truth: Lectures at the College de France 1983–1984. Trans. Graham Burchell. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Foucault, M. (2012). The history of sexuality, vol. 3: The care of the self. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Foucault, M. (2017). Subjectivity and truth: lectures at the College de France, 1980-1981. Springer.
Fuschillo, G. (2020). Fans, fandoms, or fanaticism?. Journal of Consumer Culture, 20(3), 347-365.
Gn, J. (2011). Queer simulation: The practice, performance and pleasure of cosplay. Continuum, 25(4), 583-593.
Heinderyckx, F. (2015). Gatekeeping theory redux. In Gatekeeping in transition (pp. 253-268). Routledge.
Holt, D. B. (2017). Consumer culture strategy. In Contemporary consumer culture theory (pp. 215-224). Routledge.
Jacobsen, M. H., & Hansen, A. R. (2021). (Re) introducing embodied practical understanding to the sociology of sustainable consumption. Journal of Consumer Culture, 21(4), 747-763.
Jenkins, H. (2006). Fans, bloggers, and gamers: Exploring participatory culture. NYU Press.
Keller, K. L., & Kotler, P. (2022). Branding in B2B firms. In Handbook of business-to-business marketing (pp. 205-224). Edward Elgar Publishing.
Korai, B., & Souiden, N. (2019). The marketing discipline in trouble? Academic voices vying for supremacy. Management decision, 57(9), 2555-2569.
Kozinets, R. V., & Jenkins, H. (2022). Consumer movements, brand activism, and the participatory politics of media: A conversation. Journal of Consumer Culture, 22(1), 264-282.
Kozinets, R. V. (2020). Netnography: The essential guide to qualitative social media research. Doing ethnographic research online. New York: Sage.
Lynch, K. S. (2022). Fans as transcultural gatekeepers: The hierarchy of BTS’Anglophone Reddit fandom and the digital East-West media flow. New media & society, 24(1), 105-121.
Mikkonen, I., Moisander, J., & Fırat, A. F. (2011). Cynical identity projects as consumer resistance–the Scrooge as a social critic? Consumption, Markets and Culture, 14(1), 99-116.
Mikkonen, I., Vicdan, H., & Markkula, A. (2014). What not to wear? Oppositional ideology, fashion, and governmentality in wardrobe self-help. Consumption Markets & Culture, 17(3), 254-273.
Moura, B. M., & de Souza-Leão, A. L. M. (2023). Cosplay aesthetics: fans poach for a beautiful life. Revista FAMECOS, 30(1), 1-16.
Moura, B. M., & Souza-Leão, A. L. M. D. (2024). Avatar of the self: Governing meta-body elaborated based on embodiments of consumption. Revista Brasileira de Gestão de Negócios, 26(1), e20230002.
Obiegbu, C. J., Larsen, G., Ellis, N., & O’Reilly, D. (2019). Co-constructing loyalty in an era of digital music fandom: An experiential-discursive perspective. European Journal of Marketing, 53(3), 463-482.
Scott, S. (2019). Interrogating the Fake Geek Girl: The Spreadable Misogyny of Contemporary Fan Culture. In Fake Geek Girls (pp. 76-108). New York University Press.
Sakdiyakorn, M., & Chirakranont, R. (2024). Brewing social capital: A case study of Thailand’s craft beer consumption community. Journal of Consumer Culture, 24(4), 400-419.
Seregina, A., & Weijo, H. A. (2017). Play at any cost: How cosplayers produce and sustain their ludic communal consumption experiences. Journal of Consumer Research, 44(1), 139-159.
Shoemaker, P. J., & Vos, T. P. (2014). Media gatekeeping. In An integrated approach to communication theory and research (pp. 89-103). Routledge.
Sihvonen, A., Luoma, J., & Falk, T. (2021). How customer knowledge affects exploration: Generating, guiding, and gatekeeping. Industrial Marketing Management, 94, 90-105.
Skålén, P. (2009). Service marketing and subjectivity: the shaping of customer-oriented employees. Journal of Marketing Management, 25(7-8), 795-809.
Souza-Leão, A. L. M. D., Ferreira, B. R. T., & Moura, B. M. (2024). Cynical fan: telling the truth shamelessly. Cadernos EBAPE. BR, 22(1), e2023-0032.
Thompson, C. J. (2017). Canonical Authors in Consumption Theory. In Askegaard, S. & Heilbrunn, B. (Eds.), Producing foucaldians: consumer culture theory and the analytics of power (pp. 212–220). New York: Routledge.
Thompson, C. J. (2019). The ‘big data’myth and the pitfalls of ‘thick data’opportunism: On the need for a different ontology of markets and consumption. Journal of Marketing Management, 35(3-4), 207-230.
Thompson, C. J., Henry, P. C., & Bardhi, F. (2018). Theorizing reactive reflexivity: Lifestyle displacement and discordant performances of taste. Journal of Consumer Research, 45(3), 571-594.
Vos, T. P. (2015). Revisiting gatekeeping theory during a time of transition. In Gatekeeping in transition (pp. 3-24). Routledge.
Wallace, J. (2017). Modelling Contemporary Gatekeeping: The rise of individuals, algorithms and platforms in digital news dissemination. Digital Journalism, 6(3), 274–293
Webster Jr, F. E., & Wind, Y. (1972). A general model for understanding organizational buying behavior. Journal of marketing, 36(2), 12-19.
Winge, T. (2006). Costuming the imagination: Origins of anime and manga cosplay. Mechademia, 1(1), 65-76.
Zwick, D., & Denegri Knott, J. (2009). Manufacturing customers: The database as new means of production. Journal of Consumer Culture, 9(2), 221-247.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Bruno Melo Moura, André Luiz Maranhão de Souza-Leão
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
