Why couldn't early modern China make the leap to capitalism? A neomarxist approach
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1590/0103-20702015211Abstract
In this paper, we bear on the Marxist debate on the transition from feudalism to capitalism to ask the following question: why couldn't Early Modern China make the leap to capitalism, as we have come to know it in the West? Concluding that it is unwarranted to search in class conflict per se the key to explaining such transition, we seek to answer the question with which we named this article by calling upon the "Braudelian/Arrighian school of Political Economy," which draws a distinction between capitalism and the market economy. Following this distinction, we suggest that, even if China compared well with the West in key economic features - commercialization and commodification of goods, land, labor - up to the 18th century, as Gunder Frank argues in hisReOrient, it did not traverse the path to Capitalism, in the Braudelian sense of the word, because of the "fact of empire". Lacking the scale of fiscal difficulties encountered in Early Modern Europe, Late Imperial China did not have to heavily tax merchants and notables; therefore, it did not have to negotiate rights and duties with the mercantile class. In other words, Chinese officials did not have to make concessions to the nascent-capitalist class, concessions that granted European economic elites an unprecedented voice in government, with which they enacted reforms that all societies had previously thought unnatural.Downloads
References
Allen, Robert C. (2009), “Agricultural productivity and rural incomes in England and the Yangtze Delta, c. 1620-1820”. Economic History Review, 62 (3): 525-550.
Appel, Tiago Nasser. (2012), Domando o Leviatã: como compramos a liberdade através dos impostos. Dissertação de mestrado. Curitiba, ufpr.
Arrighi, Giovanni. (1994), The long twentieth century: money, power, and the origins of our times. Londres, Verso.
Braudel, Fernand. (1977), Afterthoughts on material civilization and capitalism. Trad. Patricia M. Ranum. Londres, Johns Hopkins University Press.
Bray, Francesca. (1999), “Towards a critical history of non-western technology”. In: Brook, Timothy & Blue, Gregory (orgs.). China and historical capitalism. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Brenner, Robert. (1976), “Agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe”. Past and Present, 70: 30-75.
______. (1977), “The origins of capitalist development: a critique of neo-smithian Marxism”. New Left Review, 104 (1): 25-92.
Brenner, Robert & Isett, Christopher. (2002), “England’s divergence from China’s Yangzi Delta: property relations, microeconomics and patterns of development”. The Journal of Asian Studies, 61 (2): 609-662.
Brewer, John. (1989), The sinews of power: war, money and the English State, 1688-1783. Londres, Unwin Hyman.
Broadberry, Stephen & Gupta, Bishnupriya. (2006), “The early modern great divergence: wages, prices and economic development in Europe and Asia, 1500-1800”. Economic History Review, 59 (1): 2-31.
Bryant, Joseph M. (2006), “The West and the rest revisited: debating capitalist origins, European colonialism and the advent of modernity”. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 31 (4): 403-445.
Dobb, Maurice. (1947), Studies in the development of capitalism. Nova York, International Publishers.
______. (1977), “Um comentário suplementar”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
______. (1977), “Uma Réplica”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Elvin, Mark. (1973), The pattern of the Chinese past. Stanford, ca, Stanford University Press.
Fiori, José Luís. (2009), “O poder global e a nova geopolítica das nações”. Crítica y Emancipación, 2: 157-183.
Frank, Andre Gunder. (1998), ReOrient: global economy in the Asian age. Los Angeles, University of California Press.
Gates, Hill. (1996), China’s motor: a thousand years of petty capitalism. Ithaca, ny, Cornell University Press.
Goldstone, Jack A. (2008), “Capitalist origins, the advent of modernity, and coherent explanation: a response to Joseph M. Bryant”. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 33 (1):119-133.
Hall, John A. (1985), Powers and liberties: the causes and consequences of the rise of the West. Berkeley, ca, University of California Press.
Hill, Christopher. (1977), “Um comentário”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Hilton, Rodney. (1977), “Capitalismo: o que representa esta palavra?”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Hilton, Rodney. (1977), “Um comentário”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Ho, Ping-ti. (1954), “The salt merchants of Yang-Chou: a study of commercial capitalism in eighteenth-century China”. Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies, 17 (1/2): 130-168.
Huang, Philip, C. C. (2002), “Development or involution in eighteenth-century Britain and China? A review of Kenneth Pomeranz’s The greater divergence: China, Europe, and the making of the modern world economy”. The Journal of Asian Studies, 61 (2): 501-538.
Jones, E. L. (1987), The European miracle: environments, economies and geopolitics in the history of Europe and Asia. 2. ed. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Lachmann, Richard. (1989), “Origins of capitalism in Western Europe: economic and political aspects”. Annual Review of Sociology, 15: 47-72.
Lefebvre, Georges. (1977), “Algumas observações”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Lin, Justin Yifu. (1995), “The Needham puzzle: why the industrial revolution did not originate in China”. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 43 (2): 269-292.
MacFarlane, Alan. (1978), The origins of English individualism: the family, property and social transition. Oxford, Wiley.
Marx, Karl. ([1894] 1996), Capital: a critique of political economy. Vol. 3: The process of capitalist production as a whole. Ed. Friedrich Engels. On-line version: Marx.org. Disponível em www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ch20.htm, consultado em 3/10/2013.
Mokyr, Joel. (1990), The lever of riches: technological creativity and economic progress. Nova York, Oxford University Press.
North, Douglass C. & Thomas, Robert Paul. (1973), The rise of the western world: a new economic history. Nova York, Cambridge University Press.
Pomeranz, Kenneth. (2000), The great divergence: China, Europe, and the making of the modern world-economy. Princeton, nj, Princeton University Press.
Procacci, Giuliano. (1977), “Uma sinopse do debate”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Robinson, William I. (2011), “Globalization and the sociology of Immanuel Wallerstein: a critical appraisal”. Sociological Analysis, 3: 75-95.
Rosenthal, Jean-Laurent & Wong, R. Bin. (2011), Before and Beyond Divergence: the politics of economic change in China and Europe. Cambridge, ma, Harvard University Press.
Sweezy, Paul. (1977), “Uma crítica”. In: Sweezy, Paul et al. (orgs.). A transição do feudalismo para o capitalismo. 5. ed. Trad. Isabel Didonnet. Rio de Janeiro, Paz e Terra.
Teschke, Benno. (2003), The myth of 1648: class, geopolitics and the making of modern international relations. Londres, Verso.
Wallerstein, Immanuel. (1974), The modern world system I: capitalist agriculture and the origins of the European world-economy in the sixteenth-century. Nova York, Academic Press.
______. (1999), “The West, capitalism, and the modern world-system”. In: Brook, Timothy & Blue, Gregory (orgs.). China and historical capitalism. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
______. (2004), World-system analysis: an introduction. Durham, nc, Duke University Press.
Wang, Gungwu. (1990), “Merchants without empire: the Hokkien sojourning communities”. In: Tracy, James (org.). The rise of merchant empires: long-distance trade in the early modern world, 1350-1750. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press,
Wong, R. Bin. (1999), “The political economy of agrarian empire and its modern legacy”. In: Brook, Timothy & Blue, Gregory (orgs.). China and historical capitalism. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2015 Tempo Social
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
