The Controversy Between Júlio Ribeiro and Alberto Sales

an Analysis of The Debate about the Ideal Model of Organization Of Sciences and the Appropriate Use of Theoretical References in the Linguistic Production in Brazil in the Nineteenth Century

Authors

  • José Edicarlos de Aquino Universidade Federal do Tocantins

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.2236-4242.v32i1p129-153

Keywords:

Júlio Ribeiro, Alberto Sales, Controversy, Organization of the Sciences, Plagiarism

Abstract

In this article, based on the accusation of plagiarism addressed to Júlio Ribeiro by Alberto Sales, we analyze the conflicting positions about the ideal model of the organization of sciences and, above all, the use of theoretical references in the linguistic production in Brazil in the 19th century, such as the importance of classical studies and the conception of education. Leaving aside the moral dimension of the issue regarding plagiarism, what matters to us is to think that, further than being a simple copy, there is a whole work of re-signification upon the theoretical references on the part of Júlio Ribeiro, arguing that he demonstrates understanding of metalinguistics transfer between languages from the Greco-Latin grammar tradition to the composition of a grammar.

Downloads

Downloads

Published

2019-04-11

Issue

Vol. 32 No. 1 (2019): An Invitation to the History of Sciences of Language

Section

Articles

License

Copyright (c) 2019 Linha D'Água

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

The Editorial Board authorizes free access to and distribution of published contentes, provided that the source is cited, that is, granding credit to the authors and Linha D'Água and preserving the full text. The author is allowed to place the final version (postprint / editor’s PDF) in an institutional/thematic repositor or personal page (site, blog), immediately after publication, provided that it is available for open access and comes without any embargo period. Full reference should be made to the first publication in Linha D'Água. Access to the paper should at least be aligned with the access the journal offers.

As a legal entity, the University of São Paulo at Ribeirão Preto School of Philosophy, Sciences and Languages owns and holds the copyright deriving from the publication. To use the papers, Paidéia adopts the Creative Commons Licence, CC BY-NC non-commercial attribution. This licence permits access, download, print, share, reuse and distribution of papers, provided that this is for non-commercial use and that the source is cited, giving due authorship credit to Linha D'Água. In these cases, neither authors nor editors need any permission.

Partial reproduction of other publications

Citations of more than 500 words, reproductions of one or more figures, tables or other illustrions should be accompanied by written permission from the copyright owner of the original work with a view to reproduction in Linha D'Água. This permission has to be addressed to the author of the submitted manuscript. Secondarily obtained rights will not be transferred under any circumstance.

How to Cite

AQUINO, José Edicarlos de. The Controversy Between Júlio Ribeiro and Alberto Sales: an Analysis of The Debate about the Ideal Model of Organization Of Sciences and the Appropriate Use of Theoretical References in the Linguistic Production in Brazil in the Nineteenth Century. Linha D’Água, São Paulo, v. 32, n. 1, p. 129–153, 2019. DOI: 10.11606/issn.2236-4242.v32i1p129-153. Disponível em: https://revistas.usp.br/linhadagua/article/view/152493.. Acesso em: 7 apr. 2025.